A third-party hotline is a crucial tool for fostering ethical conduct and transparency within any organization. However, simply having a hotline isn’t enough. Its effectiveness hinges on employee awareness, trust, and active use. This article outlines strategies to jumpstart hotline usage and maximize the value of your hotline.
From Announcement to Activation: A Multi-Pronged Approach to Increasing Hotline Usage
Getting employees to use your third-party hotline requires a concerted effort focused on communication, trust-building, and demonstrating its value. The following strategies should be used to gain employee buy-in:
Consistent Communication: The Corporate Compliance Insights article, “Keeping Your Whistleblower Hotline Alive,” by Ron Kral states, “Ongoing education, messaging and marketing efforts are critical to help ensure that people understand the purpose of the hotline, as well as when and how to use it.” Don’t just announce the hotline once. Regularly promote its use through various channels:
- Leadership Endorsement: Leaders at all levels should actively champion the hotline and demonstrate their commitment to taking reports seriously.
- Training & Onboarding: Integrate hotline information into onboarding and compliance training. Emphasize the importance of reporting and the company’s anti-retaliation policy.
- Intranet & Email: Feature prominent banners and dedicated pages explaining the hotline’s purpose, how it works, and the types of concerns to report. Send periodic reminders, including (anonymized) success stories.
- Visual Reminders: Display posters and flyers in common areas like break rooms and restrooms.
Building Trust and Confidentiality: Employees need to believe their reports will be taken seriously and that they’ll be protected from retaliation:
- Anonymity & Confidentiality: Clearly explain how the hotline protects reporter identities and ensures confidentiality throughout the investigation process.
- Non-Retaliation Policy: Fraud Magazine’s article, “Top 10 Factors Leading to Hotline Distrust,” states, “Organizations should communicate they have a zero tolerance policy for retaliation and will deal with it swiftly and publicly. They might need to conduct ongoing communications and awareness campaigns to make programs as transparent and trustworthy as possible especially if employees know about previous retaliations.”
- Transparency in Outcomes: Share aggregated data on the outcomes of investigations (while maintaining confidentiality), to demonstrate that reports lead to tangible actions and improvements.
Ease of Use: Demonstrate the hotline’s accessibility and user-friendly features. Highlight the following:
- Multiple Reporting Channels: Show various ways to report concerns (phone, online portal, mail, etc.).
- Multilingual Support: Demonstrate how to access the hotline in all relevant languages.
- Clear Instructions: Provide simple, easy-to-follow instructions during training and share these instructions for future reference in all relevant languages.
Regular Review and Evaluation: Assess the hotline’s effectiveness:
- Track Reporting Trends: Analyze reports to identify potential risk areas.
- Solicit Feedback: Gather employee feedback on their perceptions of the hotline.
- Update Communication: Adjust your strategy based on data and feedback.
- Annual Acknowledgements: Require a sign-off acknowledging familiarity with the hotline during annual reviews. This will also strengthen your affirmative defense.
Positioning as an Employee Benefit: A Small Investment, Big Impact
A robust third-party hotline isn’t just a compliance tool; it’s a valuable employee benefit. It contributes to a safer, more ethical, and transparent work environment. Framing your third-party hotline as an employee benefit demonstrates that your organization cares about the wellbeing of employees and are committed to doing what’s right. When discussing your hotline, focus on the following benefits:
- A Voice: The hotline gives employees a voice, ensuring their concerns are heard and investigated independently.
- Protection: It safeguards against unethical behavior, protecting employees from potential harm.
- Enhanced Trust: Demonstrating a commitment to transparency builds trust between employees and management.
- Peace of Mind: Knowing a confidential reporting mechanism exists offers psychological safety. Employees feel empowered to address concerns without fear.
Crucially, few employee benefits are as meaningful, especially at such a low per-employee cost. The cost of implementing and maintaining a hotline is minimal compared to the potential costs of litigation, reputational damage, or low employee morale stemming from unresolved ethical issues. Consider findings from the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners’ Occupational Fraud 2024: A Report to the Nations.
The study found that the fraudulent activity uncovered by law enforcement lasted an average of 24 months and resulted in an average loss of $675,000, and fraud schemes uncovered by external audits lasted an average of 18 months, resulting in an average loss of $227,000. That said, fraudulent activity uncovered by tips lasted an average of 12 months, resulting in an average loss of $155,000. The implication: issues are detected sooner, resulting in less damage, when a hotline is in place. Implementing a third-party hotline is a small investment that yields significant returns in terms of a healthier, more ethical, and more productive workplace.
In summary, jumpstarting hotline use requires a deliberate and multifaceted strategy that moves beyond mere implementation. Rather than passively waiting for reports, organizations must actively cultivate a culture of engagement.
- Consistent communication, emphasizing leadership endorsement and readily accessible training, ensures employees are aware of the hotline’s existence and purpose.
- Building trust through demonstrated confidentiality, a clear non-retaliation policy, and sharing positive outcomes is paramount.
- Simplifying access with multiple reporting channels and multilingual support further removes barriers to utilization.
- Finally, ongoing evaluation and adaptation based on feedback and reporting trends allows for continuous improvement, ensuring the hotline remains a relevant and effective tool.
By prioritizing these proactive measures, organizations can effectively jumpstart hotline use, making it a vital component of their ethical infrastructure.
For more hotline usage best practices, visit our blog here and then click on “hotlines” on the menu bar.
Reach Us
Red Flag Reporting
P.O. Box 4230, Akron, Ohio 44321
Tel: 877-676-6551
Fax: 330-572-8146