• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • File a Report
  • Check Report
  • Client Login

Red Flag Reporting

Protecting Organizations & Their People

  • Home
  • About RFR
    • Our Team and Expertise
    • Who Do We Help?
    • Published Articles
  • Services
    • Hotline Service
    • Compliance Services
  • Benefits
    • Protect Employees
    • Protect Your Reputation
    • Protect Your Bottom Line
    • Manage Cases with Ease
  • Blog
  • Get Started
    • FAQ
    • Request a Demo or Quote
  • Contact Us

May 6, 2020

Reframing the Connotation of a Whistleblowing Hotline

Share on LinkedIn Share
Share on Facebook Share
Share on TwitterTweet

The act of whistleblowing is often perceived through a negative lens. The thought is that if someone files a report, the company must be seriously flawed, or the whistleblower is overreacting. The truth is that whistleblowing is a natural part of maintaining the integrity of an organization, often times addressing a problem before it spirals out of control. Kyle Welch and Stephen Stubben conducted research on the function of internal whistleblowing, using data from a large, international hotline provider. Welch reported their findings in “The Value of Whistleblowing and Hotline Reporting,” published by Security Magazine. Their discoveries, which shed a positive light on whistleblowing, are discussed below.

Welch reports that higher hotline volume correlated with greater return on assets. He and Stubben also found that greater hotline use was linked to less material lawsuits and 20.4% lower settlement costs when lawsuits did occur. Clearly, the increased use of hotlines to report concerns was not indicative of greater problems within the organization. Instead, employees within these organizations shed light on concerns before they were severe enough to cause negative publicity and higher avoidable costs. In fact, Welch and Stubben found that organizations with greater hotline use had less external whistleblowing and an average of 46% fewer negative news stories than those who infrequently reported concerns internally. Clearly, the issues identified via internal hotline reports have serious potential to cause greater harm if left unreported.

What is even more surprising is that after analyzing two million hotline reports, Welch and Stubben found that secondhand reports, those reports from individuals not directly involved in an incident, were actually more credible than firsthand reports. This is an interesting discovery given that the details of an event are thought to be bent as news travels from witnesses to others. After discussing these findings with multiple chief compliance officers, they reached the conclusion that secondhand reports are less likely to be biased due to personal motivation and that secondhand reporters are often less fearful of potential retaliation.

The findings from the research conducted by Welch and Stubben serve as another reminder of the importance of whistleblowing hotlines. No organization wants to be surprised by internal reports uncovering the development of a major internal problem, but such a secret is much more severe when it is left unexposed for a long period of time or is first reported externally. Many hotlines such as Red Flag Reporting allow whistleblowers to remain anonymous, further encouraging reporting by decreasing the fear of retaliation. Encouraging the use of whistleblower hotlines empowers employees to help maintain the integrity and viability of their organization.

Share on LinkedIn Share
Share on Facebook Share
Share on TwitterTweet

Filed Under: Uncategorized

We are Red Flag Reporting

We offer ethics, safety and fraud hotline / case management solutions to our clients via the web, over the phone and through other methods. Trusted by organizations large and small in 50 countries, we can help you!

We are an Ethics Hotline Service Provider
Find Out More  Get a Quote

Primary Sidebar

Hotline and Web Portal

We are an Ethics Hotline Service Provider

Get a Quote

We offer ethics, safety and fraud hotline / case management solutions to our clients via the web, over the phone and through other methods. Trusted by organizations large and small in 50 countries, we can help you!

Red Flag Reporting is Hiring!

About Red Flag Reporting Founded in 2010, …

[Read Article...] about Red Flag Reporting is Hiring!

Best Practices for Preventing a Workplace Retaliation Claim

Retaliation is the most frequent type of claim …

[Read Article...] about Best Practices for Preventing a Workplace Retaliation Claim

Internal Whistleblowers Face Few Protections: Why This Matters

The decision to become a whistleblower is never …

[Read Article...] about Internal Whistleblowers Face Few Protections: Why This Matters

Footer

Follow Along

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Red Flag Reporting

Red Flag Reporting provides compliance and ethics hotline services and case management software solutions to organizations seeking to promote safe and ethical behavior.

Reach Us

Red Flag Reporting
P.O. Box 4230, Akron, Ohio 44321
Contact Us

(Sales Office only – not a reporting line)
Tel: 877-676-6551
Fax: 330-572-8146

NOTE: Red Flag Reporting services are available for purchase by organizations only. We do not sell or provide our services to individual people.

  

 

Copyright © 2023 Red Flag Reporting all rights reserved. All other trademarks and copyrights are the property of their respective holders.

  • Red Flag Reporting – Ethics, Fraud and Whistleblower Hotline Service
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy